At 18:43 9/2/02, Brian Swale wrote:
Hi folk,
I have a friend of many years' standing with whom I used to share a flat in
New Zealand in the 1970s, and who works for the USDAFS in the WV / MD
area. He spends a lot of time talking to classes and projecting slides. Now
he's thinking of digital. My first question was "Why?".
[snip]
Responses appreciated.
Brian,
My question is also "Why?"
I presume he is projecting to at least a 60 inch screen, if not something
approaching an 80 inch. Very large screens are commonly found in schools
and other commercial settings. Now imagine using a typical digital
photograph and exploding it to that size. This is ***not*** the same as
line art which fares reasonably well in digital projection.
The beauty of the slow and medium speed 35mm slide films are their extreme
fine grain. Even if projection size exceeds resolving power of the film,
as it can easily do, it degrades gracefully without falling apart. Not so
with digitals. In the attempts I've seen projecting digital photographs to
a large screen at work using something close to reasonable file sizes, the
images fall apart completely with outright ugly pixelation. Do the math to
find the size of an individual pixel in a digital image of *reasonable*
file size when it's projected to a 72 inch screen. For a 1024x768 file
they're about 1/16th inch square. Now compound this with common, lossy
compression techniques used to make reasonable file sizes of them (which
likely has greatest uglification effect).
I recommend considering conversion digital for this purpose very carefully
and would want to ***see*** projections of photographs ***before*** buying
a camera or digital projector, and be ***certain*** of the exact process
used to replicate anything that looks OK. This has been an utter failure
where I work using common digital cameras in the 3MP range and common
digital projectors for "Powerpoint" presentations. It was a BIG surprise
to those who tried it ("Gee, it looked just fine on the [17 inch] computer
screen.") but it was no surprise to me.
Perhaps someone else on the list has been able to project digital
photographs of *reasonable* file size to large screens using digital
projectors. If so, I'd certainly like to know how it was done (and the
file sizes). Nobody where I work has been able to do it yet, and we have
no shortage of techno-geeks.
-- John
< This message was delivered via the Olympus Mailing List >
< For questions, mailto:owner-olympus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx >
< Web Page: http://Zuiko.sls.bc.ca/swright/olympuslist.html >
|