Periodically Pop Photo or another magazine would publish an article about
off-brand or house label films (Target, Walgreen's, Reel Good Film, Bud's
Back Alley Film, etc.), but I haven't seen such an article updated recently.
Here are a few I've tried and believe I've identified accurately:
Polaroid (usually labeled "One Film"): if the box says Made In Germany it's
Agfa, probably HDC. I've seen this film only in 100 and 200 ASA. Good
stuff, saturated colors.
Polaroid (usually labeled "High Definition"): if the box says Made In Japan
or Made In The Netherlands it's Fuji, probably Super HQ. At least the
results resemble Super HQ. Less saturated than Polaroid One Film. Sharper?
Maybe. Available in 100-400 ASA. Pretty good stuff, nothing special,
nothing wrong, I just prefer Fuji Superia.
BEWARE: I've seen at least one batch of Polaroid High Definition film made
in the USA. Avoid - this is Imation/3M film, a manufacturer of many house
brand films and usually disappointing. Kodak film is not sold under any
other label to the best of my knowledge.
Walgreen's film is all Agfa, labeled Made In Germany. A real bargain. My
favorite house brand film. ASA 100-400 available and all have been very
satisfactory, tho' best suited to landscapes due to the saturated colors.
(Those of you who took a peek at my photos of Kathryn on PhotoPoint may have
noticed her face looked pale compared with her arms. That's the drawback to
using a saturated color film rather than something like Portra. My photos
of her from the same session using my last roll of Kodak VPS were more
flattering to her skin tones. Unfortunately the photos themselves weren't
quite as interesting.)
Winn-Dixie (a Southwestern U.S. supermarket chain) film is Ferrania, perhaps
the world's worst film. I'm assuming that Ferrania must make some good film
sold under its own name, but whatever it makes for house brand relablers is
awful. Avoid at all costs.
Other places I've seen selling relabeled Ferrania film include other
supermarket chains, the various "Dollar" stores, etc. If the label says
Made In Italy, well...if you want to support the Italian economy, buy olive
oil or a Ferrari. Or buy Kodak film and take a holiday in Italy and spend
lavishly.
Summary: if a house brand film is Made In USA or Made In Italy, skip it. If
it's made in Japan, The Netherlands or Germany, it's worth trying.
JMHOOC.
Lex
===
Date: Mon, 22 Jan 2001 23:02:39 -0800
From: "Mickey Trageser" <mickeytr@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
...Off brand films are a gamble...
_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com
< This message was delivered via the Olympus Mailing List >
< For questions, mailto:owner-olympus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx >
< Web Page: http://Zuiko.sls.bc.ca/swright/olympuslist.html >
|