NEC's Spectraview colorimeter doesn't give accurate profiles with non-NEC
monitors and software; it is a little different than the regular i1
Display II device.
You can't change the CIE xy values, they are the actual color of the
screen's red, blue, and green pixels. Accurate measurement of them is
important to making a profile. Monitor calibration is actually two
separate things. Calibration has you adjust the screen's brightness,
contrast, and color to as close as it can get to the ideal, then a profile
is made by measuring the actual values the monitor is producing and
creating an ICC profile that tells color managed software like Photoshop
how the screen displays color, so it can adjust the display of images to
compensate for the slight inaccuracy in the calibration or deficiencies in
the screen's color gamut.
You'll never get the laptop screen to match your NEC screen. The NEC has
internal lookup tables that allow it to adjust its white point with no
loss of color gamut, unlike most LCDs, which really cannot change their
white point (CRTs can, but LCDs cannot because of how they display
color...the backlight in an LCD is a certain color temperature and you're
kinds stuck with that on most LCDs).
I believe xrite's software requires you to manually change the screen
brightness during the calibration steps, it doesn't do it automatically.
That is probably why your screen is coming out too bright.
--
Chris Crawford
Fine Art Photography
Fort Wayne, Indiana
260-437-8990
http://www.chriscrawfordphoto.com My portfolio
http://blog.chriscrawfordphoto.com My latest work!
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Christopher-Crawford/48229272798
Become a fan on Facebook
On 12/2/11 8:24 AM, "Bob Whitmire" <bwhitmire@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>On the subject of monitor calibration, I've run into an interesting if
>annoying issue.
>
>For more than a year, I've been using a NEC PA271w attached to an elderly
>Mac Pro tower. Love it. The profile sets 'em up near perfect for my
>printers. Couldn't be happier. You have to spend a whole lot more money
>to see any improvement over the NEC.
>
>Just recently, I acquired a refurbished-but-latest-model 17" MacBook Pro
>with all bells and whistles, including the matte screen. The NEC connects
>through Apple's new Thunderbolt technology, and again, it's pretty much
>spot on as far as output of prints.
>
>For calibration, I use NEC's Spectraview II system, which comes with a
>specially designed x-rite i1 puck.
>
>For the MacBook's monitor, however, I use x-rite's i1 Profiler D2 Lion
>Edition. The calibration is nowhere near as accurate as the Spectraview
>on the NEC. I know that a laptop's monitor is not going to equal the
>dedicated NEC, but it seems like I ought to be able to get them a lot
>closer than they are. And yes, the MacBook supports dual monitors and
>dual .icc profiles. I've even disconnected the NEC to profile the MacBook
>and used the MacBook in clamshell (closed) mode to profile the NEC.
>
>Asked the question elsewhere, and someone said in order to get them
>closer, I would have to mess with the CIE x,y values, which I notice is
>possible in the i1 Lion software. But I haven't a clue as how to do it or
>exactly what I'm doing. Before I tuck in to another unwanted education
>module, I thought I'd ask here and see if there's a down and dirty answer
>or workaround to get the MacBook in shape. (I did try Apple's eyeball
>calibration and that _really_ sucked.)
>
>At home, it's not a problem, I use the NEC with the MBP is clamshell and
>it's all good. But if I'm away from the NEC, I'd like to think I'm not
>straying too far in post processing. I know in recent years monitor
>manufacturers including Apple have been more interested in multimedia
>applications such as video and gaming and such, which is the only reason
>I can think of that Apple would make glossy screens standard. I had to
>pay extra for the matte screen on the MBP. The MBP's screen is also
>inordinately bright, which is fine for watching movies or stupid stuff on
>youtube, but not so much for editing photos. X-rite says it adjusts the
>luminance of the monitor during profiling, but when I reprofile the
>luminance shows up in the 160 range instead of the 120 range where I want
>it.
>
>So, any thoughts? What is the whole CIE x,y thing anyway? <g>
>
>--Perplexed and annoyed in Round Pond
>
>
>--
>_________________________________________________________________
>Options: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/listinfo/olympus
>Archives: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/private/olympus/
>Themed Olympus Photo Exhibition: http://www.tope.nl/
>
--
_________________________________________________________________
Options: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/listinfo/olympus
Archives: http://lists.thomasclausen.net/mailman/private/olympus/
Themed Olympus Photo Exhibition: http://www.tope.nl/
|